Updated HD DVD vs Blu-ray DVD Stats
Some sales stats from a recent article in the Sydney Morning Herald…
- 85% of high def disc sales are Blu-ray
- From Jan - Sept 2007, 81,219 Blu-ray discs were sold vs 14,632 HD DVD discs
- 24 of the top 25 HD titles were Blu-ray. “300″ was the only big selling HD DVD disc which ranked 20th.
- Only 1,644 Blu-ray players had been sold so far this year (not counting the 84,000 PS3 consoles) vs 528 HD DVD players
Figures were supplied by GfK.
Link:
http://www.smh.com.au/news/articles/hd-dvd-aims-to-drive-sales-with-price-cut/2007/10/15/1192300655298.html
Generally, I find the quality of reporting by “technology reporters” in newspapers or morning news programs to be poor. Sections such as following for example are quite disappointing:
“The HD DVD camp is banking on the latest round of player price cuts to drive sales in the lead up to Christmas. Presumably, the fact that HD DVD is an extension of the existing DVD format, rather than an entirely new technology like Blu-ray, has allowed disc and player manufacturers to reduce their production costs quickly.”
HD DVD and Blu-ray have more in common with each other than either of them have in common with DVD and why propagate the disc manufacturing cost myth? It’s probably just due to muddle headed thinking.
The disc replication cost of the two formats is essentially equivalent, with Blu-ray being cheaper per gigabyte. Getting the pricing information from any actual, factual disc replicator is proof enough of that. Here’s one:
http://www.proactionmedia.com/
Blu-ray will achieve economies of scale more rapdily than HD DVD. Not only are more discs getting moved for high definition movies, but every PS3 game on the shelf is on a Blu-ray disc. The hardware is proliferating. 5 million PS3s world wide now, bound to be many more after Christmas. It’s regrettable that HD DVD is going to thrash around for another 18 months or so. Particularly as flagship HD DVD titles can’t deliver all the audio options due to space limitations:
http://hddvd.highdefdigest.com/1110/transformers.html
I’m sure the 1.5mbps English Dolby track sounds great, but it could have sounded better. And that, frankly, is entirely the point when it comes to high definition discs.